Shing Mun Redoubt

Shing Mun Redoubt

Posted: Sep 17, 2021 | Updated: Nov 11, 2024

The Gin Drinkers Line

The Gin Drinkers Line was a line comprising a string of pillboxes and other defensive structures constructed in the 1930s across the hills north of Kowloon. It stretched from Gin Drinkers Bay in the west, through the Shing Mun Reservoir, Smuggler's Ridge, Tide Cove, Tate's Cairn and Port Shelter on the east coast. You won't find Gin Drinkers Bay now; it was reclaimed in the 1960s and this former bay is now the built up areas of Kwai Fong and a part of Kwai Hing.

The Gin Drinkers Line was intended to anchor the British defence on the mainland. The key point in this was the Shing Mun Redoubt located above the Shing Mun (Jubilee) Reservoir. It was believed that the line could hold back an enemy for at least six months but the loss of the Shing Mun Redoubt only a day after the start of hostilities with the Japanese led to the abandonment of the mainland and the rapid retreat to Hong Kong Island.

The Loss of the Shing Mun Redoubt

Japan attacked the USA at Pearl Harbour on 7th December, 1941 at 07:48. By 09:00 the Japanese left scores of sunk and damaged ships, destroyed aircraft and over 2000 dead. By this point in Hong Kong it was 03:00 on the 8th December. At 04:00 the Japanese attacked Hong Kong but unlike at Pearl Harbour, the British were not taken by surprise and demolished bridges and roads to delay the Japanese advance.

The Shing Mun Redoubt was the right flank of the section defended by the 2nd Battalion Royal Scots and occupied by 8 Platoon A Coy, A Coy HQ, and observers from the Hong Kong and Singapore Royal Artillery (HKSRA). C Coy was on the left, anchored on Gin Drinkers Bay, B Coy formed the centre and D Coy was held in reserve. Along Smugglers Ridge looking down on the Shing Mun River below the dam was D Coy of the 5th Battalion, 7th Rajput Regiment.

By 15:00 on the 9th December Colonel Doi of the 228th Regiment, part of the 38th Infantry Division, Imperial Japanese Army had marched through the New Territories encountering minimal resistance and were on Needle Hill looking down upon the redoubt. Colonel Doi observed that the redoubt looked unprepared and decided on a surprise attack that night.

At 21:00 that night, the 3rd Battalion left their positions and crossed over the reservoir dam to form up just below Pillbox 401b at the north eastern end of the redoubt ,whilst clearance teams set about removing obstacles and cutting the defensive wire. By 23:00 a British sentry challenged shadowy figures around the wire which then started the shooting and the assault.

At this point there are different narratives of how the attack proceeded and for this I'll refer to the paper 'Decoding the Enigma of the Fall of the Shing Mun Redoubt Using Line of Sign Analysis' written by Lawrence W.C. Lai, Stephen N.G. Davies, Ken S.T. Ching and Castor T.Z. Wong, The Hong Kong Institute of Surveyors (2011). This really is a superb read and covers additional topics in relation to the battle.

"70th Anniversary of the Battle of Hong Kong (2011)"

In this, they investigate the rapid loss of the Shing Mun Redoubt, looking at the Japanese and British accounts, other studies that tried to answer this, and an analysis of the terrain around the Redoubt. I've also referred to the excellent book by Philip Cracknell, 'Battle for Hong Kong December 1941' (2019).

Interestingly, in Tony Banham's 2010 book, 'Not the Slightest Chance, The Defence of Hong Kong, 1941', the initial attack sees the Japanese first scale Smugglers Ridge to the east of the OP and then descend to attack, and an hour after this for an attack to be made at PB 401. Lawrence et al's work references Banham's work and the theory on show in Banham doesn't seem to be quite the case, however it is correct in that the Japanese did attack the OP, and the OP was in fact the first manned position to fall.

Was the design of the Redoubt faulty?

In 1941 some shortcomings became evident and an exercise showed that an enemy would be able to approach the Redoubt unseen. Further more, in relation to an infantry attack it was found that:

  • The ability for the pillboxes to provide mutual cover was poor.
  • Machine guns were not able to sufficiently be depressed to fire or even view some of the approaches.
  • The numerous ventilation shafts could be easily infiltrated and grenades thrown down.
  • The many openings in the tunnel network created weak points that would require men to defend.

The study by Lawrence et al found while it is true that not all of the pillboxes provided mutual cover (only PB 403), if we consider the trench positions as well, then all of the positions are covered if the Redoubt is fully manned - and here lies one of the issues.

The Gin Drinkers Line required 6 battalions to defend but these numbers of troops were never going to be available with more pressing priorities in Europe and North Africa. As a result, only 3 battalions were available to hold the line meaning that the troops were spread very thin. On the night that the Shing Mung Redoubt was attacked, only 42 defenders were available to defend a large network of tunnels, trenches and pillboxes capable of holding 120 men.

The course of the battle

As the 3rd Battalion moved to assault the redoubt, the 2nd Battalion deployed along the Shing Mun River below the dam, ready to attack Smugglers Ridge. The 1st Battalion was held in reserve to exploit a breakthrough.

9 Coy under Lt Kasugai cleared the obstacles and wire surrounding PB 401b. L/Cpl Laird on sentry duty below PB 401b noted the movement of the Japanese working their way through the wire to the pillbox. Upon being challenged the assault began and Laird made his way to the HQ at the AOB to report what had occurred to the redoubt commander, Captain 'Potato' Jones. Meanwhile, Lt Kasugai's company picketed PB 401b and swept anti-clockwise to take PB 402.

10 Coy under Lt Wakabayashi moved clockwise from the picketed PB 401b to PB 400. He possibly entered the tunnels at this point and travelled along Oxford Street and Shaftesbury Avenue, to the exit and the close by entrance to Charing Cross, as its at this exit/entrance to Shaftesbury Avenue that the famous graffiti can be found which was engraved by his troops on the wall.

From here there is an above ground route up the AOP. The Charing Cross tunnel adjacent to here also leads to the AOP via the kitchen, the Strand Palace Hotel, and the long set of steps up to the AOP. Alternatively, elements of 10 Coy might have discovered the trench outside of the kitchen and entered this way. Whichever way was used, 10 Coy managed to trap Captain Jones in the AOP. 

Jones had a poor soldierly reputation and also a reputation for partying, hence his nickname of 'Potato' given by superiors. Jones 'led' at the AOP, despite the expectation that at night time the troops should be deployed outside for better all round cover of the approaches across the dam and the redoubt itself. On the night of the attack Jones was in communication with his superiors who were concerned that Jones was not where he was expected, and that the other defenders were within the tunnels rather than in their outside positions. Jones was told to get outside and lead a counter attack. However, he had stayed inside for too long and he and other troops were trapped in the AOP.

There is some controversy about this; reports were that the AOP had been locked and that there was no other exit, and this was backed up up an inquiry afterwards. However, the inquiry did not have maps showing that this was false, any visitor today will see that it is possible to exit through the kitchen either at the trench situated just outside here, or through Charing Cross which exited close to the tunnel system connecting the pillboxes. That the defenders couldn't escape doesn't tell the full story.

Counter-attack and Withdrawal

Sgt Robb tried to lead a counter attack on the surface within the wire with about 18 men. They came under attack from the region of the 401 PBs and PB 402, and then from PB 400 and the AOP. With the Japanese in the tunnels and outside it was impossible to remain and withdrew west to the rear of the redoubt, and along Smugglers Ridge to join D Company of the Rajputs.

As it turned out, only the AOB and PB 401b was occupied, PB 401b because of the difficulty in constructing trenches on the deep slopes below the pillbox. Jones thought this was captured but it held out until the next day until a British artillery shell scored a direct hit on it, burying the defenders inside. The picketing Japanese troops rather generously given their brutal reputation during the battle dug the survivors out. Maybe because this was because the defenders hadn't actually surrendered and hence displayed the 'bushido', warrior code, thus proving themselves as worthy adversaries. 

Touching History

A visit to the Shing Mun Redoubt today will bring you across plenty of hikers as the Maclehose Trail overlaps with the redoubt, and is in fact how I first stumbled across it. This part of the trail has barbecue pits and even an ice cream vendor to cater for those less interested in hiking, and more interested in a relaxing day out among nature.

The Shing Mun Redoubt allows you to get close to the events that happened on December 9th, 1941 and a walk of the ground will teach you much more than just reading about the battle. I'd recommend reading the literature that I have noted in this blog before exploring the redoubt and the surrounding terrain.

Monkeys are a common sight so avoid fiddling in your bag, or carrying plastic bags as monkeys know that there will probably be food available to snatch.


The Highlights

  1. Tunnel exploration explore the tunnels of the anchor point of the 'Oriental Maginot Line'.
  2. Graffiti touch history and find the graffiti left by the victorious Japanese troops.
  3. Trace the battle the ruins tell the story of the battle as shrapnel damage can be traced to the course of the battle
  4. Enjoy nature and walk around the Shing Mun Reservoir but be aware of monkeys!

Posted: Nov 26, 2023 | Updated: Nov 14, 2024

Trip to Haymarket

This might be my last ever visit to the Shing Mun Redoubt due to relocation out of Hong Kong. Each time I've stepped into the redoubt I feel a connection with the past and as I've walked the tunnels I always find myself assembling the events of the past and reinterpreting the printed word. 

Haymarket Tunnel is one that I have always missed when wandering inside, hence the focus of this trip was to follow Haymarket and then to re-walk the other parts of the network, again lost in thought and re-examining the past. Previously when exploring Hong Kong's World War 2 past I have referenced Tony Banham's excellent book, 'Not the Slightest Chance, The Defence of Hong Kong, 1941' (2010). This gives a day by day, almost hour by hour, account of the battle and was the book that really fired my interest. This now tatty book was an ever constant companion on my hikes or ferry rides around Hong Kong. Philip Cracknell's, 'Battle for Hong Kong December 1941' which I referenced earlier has now taken over as my main read and was published in 2019 and also references the incredible work done by Lawrence et al which I think is the definitive account of the fall of the Shing Mun Redoubt. My understanding of this is shown diagrammatically in the last image.

Knowing that this may be my last visit, I have a good deal more photos, some from the other side of the dam looking toward the redoubt. This shows the redoubt under heavy vegetation but back in 1941 the hill sides were relatively bare. Archive footage shows this, and I've included some fascinating views of the redoubt taken from images taken from movies dating from the 1930s or even 1940s of the reservoir. This clear propaganda footage shows troops running out of the tunnels and taking up firing positions in the Shaftesbury Avenue and Regent Street trench. If there really were this many soldiers in the redoubt then the story of the fall of the Shing Mun Redoubt would be very different. Here's the video.

Prewar Propaganda at the Shing Mun Redoubt

 

1) Shing Mun Redoubt - Map
2) Shing Mun Redoubt - Reservoir Commemorative Plaque
3) Shing Mun Redoubt - Facing North East From Memorial Plaque
4) Shing Mun Redoubt - Reservoir Valve Tower
5) Shing Mun Redoubt - From Across the Dam
6) Shing Mun Redoubt - And Section of Smugglers Ridge From Across the Dam
7) Shing Mun Redoubt - Shaftesbury Avenue and Regent Street Trench Section
8) Shing Mun Redoubt - View into Regent Street
9) Shing Mun Redoubt - Regent Street Tunnel To The V Trench
10) Shing Mun Redoubt - Regent Street Exit To The V Trench
11) Shing Mun Redoubt - The Regent Street V Trench
12) Shing Mun Redoubt - Continuing on Regent Street
13) Shing Mun Redoubt - Regent Street First Stairs to Oxford Street
14) Shing Mun Redoubt - Regent Street Second Stairs to Oxford Street
15) Shing Mun Redoubt - Regent Street and Oxford Street Junction
16) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Choice of Pillboxes
17) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Entrance-Exit
18) Shing Mun Redoubt - Roof Damage At Entrance to Tunnel to Pillbox 401
19) Shing Mun Redoubt - Long Tunnel to Pillbox 401
20) Shing Mun Redoubt - Blast Evidence In Tunnel Near Pillbox 401
21) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Entrance to Pillbox 401b
22) Shing Mun Redoubt - Ruins of PB 401b
23) Shing Mun Redoubt - Ruins of PB 401b and Oxford Street Tunnel Entrance
24) Shing Mun Redoubt - Searching for PB 401a
25) Shing Mun Redoubt - Ruins of PB 401a
26) Shing Mun Redoubt - Regent Street Steps To the Trench
27) Shing Mun Redoubt - Picadilly Tunnel Trench View
28) Shing Mun Redoubt - Piccadilly and Haymarket Junction
29) Shing Mun Redoubt - Piccadilly Tunnel
30) Shing Mun Redoubt - Blocked Tunnels to Regent Palace Hotel
31) Shing Mun Redoubt - Haymarket Trench Opening
32) Shing Mun Redoubt - Haymarket Trench Position
33) Shing Mun Redoubt - End of Haymarket Leading to PB 403
34) Shing Mun Redoubt - Shaftesbury Avenue Trench
35) Shing Mun Redoubt - Shaftesbury Avenue Trench 2
36) Shing Mun Redoubt - Shaftesbury Avenue Blocked Exits
37) Shing Mun Redoubt - Back to the OP
38) Shing Mun Redoubt - The Command Post
39) Shing Mun Redoubt - Past Officers Quarters and Stair to The Kitchen
40) Shing Mun Redoubt - Looking Back To The OP past the CP and Toilet
41) Shing Mun Redoubt - Kitchen (again)
42) Shing Mun Redoubt - Kitchen From the Back
43) Shing Mun Redoubt - From Kitchen Along Charing Cross to Steps Down
44) Shing Mun Redoubt - Looking From the OP To Needle Hill
45) Shing Mun Redoubt - Satellite Photo of Attack

Posted: Mar 19, 2022 | Updated: Nov 14, 2024

Shing Mun Redoubt Revisited

Its hard to believe that it's been 10 years since I first excitedly explored the Shing Mun Redoubt. Further reading since then has raised questions that can be best answered by walking the actual tunnels and terrain - in other words by getting boots on the ground. This time I was accompanied by a smaller pair of boots so despite having questions about the battle my main focus was providing an adventurous trip through the tunnels and a bit of history.

The adventure started with a bus from Tsuen Wan to the Pineapple Dam on Shing Mun Road. A 15 minute walk from here takes you to the barbecue pits and public toiles at the start/end of Stage 6 of the Maclehose Trail.

One ice cream later we took to the trail and soon came to the first signs of the redoubt, this being around the Piccadilly tunnel. Not much further on is one of the major sights for anyone walking the trail and this is the outdoor trench at the intersection between Piccadilly, Shaftsbury Avenue and Regent Street. I always wondered why the trench was so shallow and difficult to get into the tunnels but archive footage from the 1930s shows that the trenches used to be deeper, but 83 years of surface erosion have washed a significant amount of mud into the trench.

We hopped into the trench and took the route up to Shaftesbury Avenue past the sign oft photographed sign "To O.P. & Strand Palace Hotel", and continued to PB 400. We came back the same way and left Shaftesbury Avenue at the short crossing to Charring Cross. We then headed up the steps to the OP (AOP) which is good for story telling due to the battle damage, toilet area, and long mysterious steps down to the Strand Palace Hotel (kitchen). Near here is an impressive looking piece of trench, which seems to be at it's original depth, and good for stimulating young imaginations.

1) Shing Mun Redoubt - Map
2) Shing Mun Redoubt - Easy Start Point
3) Shaftsbury Avenue and Regent Street Junction
4) Shing Mun Redoubt - To O.P & Strand Palace Hotel
5) Shing Mun Redoubt - Captured by the Wakabayashi Unit
6) Shing Mun Redoubt - Captured by the Wakabayashi Unit 2
7) Shing Mun Redoubt - Crossing From Shaftsbury Avenue To Charing Cross
8) Shing Mun Redoubt - The OP
9) Shing Mun Redoubt - Strand Palace Hotel
10) Shing Mun Redoubt - Strand Palace Hotel Trench
11) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street at the Bottom of Shaftsbury Avenue
12) Shing Mun Redoubt - PB 400
13) Shing Mun Redoubt - 3D Map

Posted: May 12, 2012 | Updated: Nov 14, 2024

The Gin Drinkers Line

I first came across the Shing Mun Redoubt when walking the Maclehose Trail. The Battle of Hong Kong is a little known battle to those in the West though I had done some reading about the topic. Most narratives of the War in the Pacific though begin with Pearl Harbour, the Philippines, Guadalcanal, Midway, island hopping towards Japan, Iwo Jima and the atomic bombs that ended the war.

Less focus is on the fall of Hong Kong, Malaya and Singapore, the War in China, and the Dutch East Indies, among other non-US campaigns. My particular interest in Hong Kong grew, particularly when learning about the defensive measures taken by the British and the rapid collapse of the Shing Mun Redoubt.

The Maclehose Trail if you are taking an East-West route will bring you to the Artillery Observation Post which lies directly on the track. This is easy to enter so I took a timeout on the hike in order to take a look inside the AOP. As I entered I had little idea of what I would find. I was thrilled and surprised to find the extent of the fortifications still in existence. From the AOP there are rooms and for me at that time, a mysterious and long, dark flight of stairs leading down to who knew where. Walking in the dark with just the light at the bottom of the tunnel to guide me, I took nervous steps down not knowing what might be in the tunnel with me. Might there be a monkey in my path in the narrow enclosed tunnel and ready to turn vicious? Bats? Snakes? Thankfully there was nothing of the sort.

I explored, came across the trench outside the kitchen that I recognised from Wikipedia, and realised that I was walking ground which years ago men fought over in terror, and that men had died in the areas that I had just walked over. I resolved to return and to explore in more detail and at a more leisurely pace. Today was the return.

Walking the tunnels can be a little scary at times in case that rogue monkey in your imagination turns out to be there. A torch is required for some sections of the tunnels. They can also be quite disorientating and a map is useful.

1) Shing Mun Redoubt - Map
2) Shing Mun Redoubt - Artillery OP
3) Shing Mun Redoubt - Artillery OP
4) Shing Mun Redoubt - Artillery OP
5) Shing Mun Redoubt - Inside the OP
6) Shing Mun Redoubt - Inside the OP
7) Shing Mun Redoubt - From the OP to the Kitchen
8) Shing Mun Redoubt - Stairs to the Kitchen
9) Shing Mun Redoubt - The Kitchen
10) Shing Mun Redoubt - The Kitchen
11) Shing Mun Redoubt - Trench Outside The Kitchen
12) Shing Mun Redoubt - Trench Outside The Kitchen
13) Shing Mun Redoubt - Trench Outside The Kitchen
14) Shing Mun Redoubt - Junction of Shaftsbury Avenue and Oxford Street
15) Shing Mun Redoubt - Regent Street Trench
16) Shing Mun Redoubt - Regent Street Trench
17) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Entrance
18) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Entrance Area
19) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Trench
20) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Trench
21) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Trench
22) Shing Mun Redoubt - Oxford Street Trench to 401 (PB)
23) Shing Mun Redoubt - PB 401b
24) Shing Mun Redoubt - Breached Tunnel on Piccadilly
25) Shing Mun Redoubt - Piccadilly Breach
26) Shing Mun Redoubt - Refreshments Area Near The Redoubt

Posted: Apr 28, 2012 | Updated: Nov 27, 2024

Walking the Shing Mun (Jubilee) Reservoir

sss

1) Shing Mun Reservoir - Peaceful Nature Walk
2) Shing Mun Reservoir - Macaques Roam the Area
3) Shing Mun Reservoir - Gentle Hills Surround the Reservoir
4) Shing Mun Reservoir - Reservoir Walk
5) Shing Mun Reservoir - Reservoir Valve Tower
6) Shing Mun Reservoir - Humid Day with Low Cloud
7) Shing Mun Reservoir - Ice Cream Time
8) Shing Mun Reservoir - Roaming Shing Mun Cows
9) Shing Mun Reservoir - Low Water Levels

Travel Hong Kong

Aberdeen

Aberdeen

Aberdeen

Bowen Road to Central

Bowen Road to Central

Bowen Road to Central

Central Police Station & Gaol

Central Police Station & Gaol

Central Police Station & Gaol

Correctional Services Museum

Correctional Services Museum

Correctional Services Museum

Devil's Peak

Devil's Peak

Devil's Peak

Hikes - Discovery Bay to Mui Wo

Hikes - Discovery Bay to Mui Wo

Hikes - Discovery Bay to Mui Wo

Hikes - Hong Kong Trail

Hikes - Hong Kong Trail

Hikes - Hong Kong Trail

Hikes - Lantau Trail

Hikes - Lantau Trail

Hikes - Lantau Trail

Hikes - Maclehose Trail

Hikes - Maclehose Trail

Hikes - Maclehose Trail

Hikes - Wilson Trail

Hikes - Wilson Trail

Hikes - Wilson Trail

Iconic Hong Kong

Iconic Hong Kong

Iconic Hong Kong

Lamma Island

Lamma Island

Lamma Island

Lyemun Fort

Lyemun Fort

Lyemun Fort

Mount Davis Battery

Mount Davis Battery

Mount Davis Battery

Ngong Ping

Ngong Ping

Ngong Ping

Pinewood Battery

Pinewood Battery

Pinewood Battery

Police Museum

Police Museum

Police Museum

Sai Wan Battery

Sai Wan Battery

Sai Wan Battery

Sai Wan Military Cemetery

Sai Wan Military Cemetery

Sai Wan Military Cemetery

Sheung Wan

Sheung Wan

Sheung Wan

Shing Mun Redoubt

Shing Mun Redoubt

Shing Mun Redoubt

Stanley

Stanley

Stanley

Tai O

Tai O

Tai O

Wong Nai Chung Gap

Wong Nai Chung Gap

Wong Nai Chung Gap

    Contact

Other Destinations in Asia

After you've experienced my delights or horrors of Hong Kong, see what the destinations below may have in store for you.

Cambodia | China | Cyprus | Hong Kong | India | Indonesia | Japan | Macao | Malaysia | Nepal | Philippines | Singapore | South Korea | Taiwan | Thailand | Turkey | United Arab Emirates | Vietnam |

Contact

Say hi!

What can I call you?
Enter your email address (this will never be shared)
It would be nice to tell us why you are contacting us!
To prevent spam mail, enter the sum of the spam captcha

Hi! I’ve been travelling since the 90's and have visited 48 countries - not many really when the world has over 240 countries and states.

I'm lucky in that I live abroad, so for me, even with COVID devastating the world, the travel experience hasn't really gone away. Anyway, I can't wait to share more of my experiences, drop me a message and I'll get back to you ASAP.